Log in

The Sadeian Woman - The Bloody Chamber [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
the Angela Carter Community

[ website | Unofficial Angela Carter Website ]
[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

The Sadeian Woman [Sep. 24th, 2006|10:37 pm]
the Angela Carter Community


In The Sadeian Woman Angela Carter gives us a re-evaluation of the work of the Marquis de Sade from a feminist perspective. She sees de Sade as the prototype of the moral pornographer. He viewed the relations between the sexes (and between the classes) honestly and without hypocrisy. He shows sex as being about power, as being a social relation that is dependent on social and political structures. He also frees female sexuality from the function of reproduction and emphasises that it is not gender that matters but power. De Sade also demonstrates an understanding of the mechanics of the female orgasm that is a little surprising when you consider the complete ignorance on that topic that prevailed through much of the following century. Carter looks at de Sade’s best-known works, particularly Justine and Juliette. The eponymous heroine of Justine believes that virtue will be rewarded, and despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary continues to believe this. She is also convinced that virtue, in a woman, is entirely a matter of sex – as long as you don’t have sex, or if you must have sex as long as you don’t enjoy it you are automatically virtuous. In fact Carter tells us that Justine’s behaviour is often astonishingly selfish and even callous because of this profound misunderstanding of the nature of virtue. Her sister Juliette does not share her delusions. She embraces vice with enthusiasm, and she gets everything she wants. The fact that she is a woman does not prevent her from gaining both wealth and power. Justine is powerless not because she is female but because she misunderstands the nature of society.

Carter also relates de Sade’s work to the way women have been depicted in Hollywood, with Marilyn Monroe being a version of Justine. The Sadeian Woman is Angela Carter at her most provocative.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

From: (Anonymous)
2007-06-18 01:30 pm (UTC)

The Sadean Women

The assesment of the the character of Justine as one believing virtue is only a matter of obstaining from obstaining from sex is plain wrong. She argues for charity gratitude and simple abstenance from cruelty in the face of gratouitous cruelty from the so called libertines.

Justine is primarily a work of pornography, little that happens is remotely believable. As far as plotline all De Sade has done is reverse the normal plot of of virtue(not just sexual virtue) being always improbably rewarded with it being always improbably being punished, with maximum low titulation.
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: wytchcroft
2008-07-27 07:38 pm (UTC)
a very good read - there's a lot to think about, argue for and against -
and i think most readers will find it more approachable than works by Kristeva,(and other theorists) covering similar ground.

On the other hand - if someone does read and enjoy The Sadean Woman (or just finds the work academically useful) then i would strongly recommend Barbara Creed's The Monstrous Feminine.
(Reply) (Thread)